Topic

Service review insights for New York, United States

Detailed Service analysis for New York, United States.

This view focuses on Service signals in New York, United States to help you understand what guests mention most.

Key takeaway

Start with the largest deviation, confirm confidence, then move through the guided journey to execute quickly.

Current scope

New York, United States

Largest gap

Benchmark comparison is loading below.

Confidence

74,599 reviews analyzed across 2 platforms.

Key Stats

Share of complaint snippets where this topic appears by platform.

This metric tracks topic presence in complaint snippets, not positive versus negative sentiment split.

Balance is praise minus complaint for this topic on the same platform.

Google Maps
Signal balance: +28.0pp

Complaint signal

9.8%

Praise signal

37.8%

Tripadvisor
Signal balance: +43.8pp

Complaint signal

11.9%

Praise signal

55.7%

Scope navigation

This topic view covers multiple categories in United States. Narrow by category when you need operationally specific comparisons.

Narrow this topic

Narrow Service analysis to indexable category or subdivision pages when you need a more specific operating context.

Related topic signals

Compare New York, United States against nearby topics before deciding whether this signal is isolated or part of a wider pattern.

Context

Coverage

1053 insight pages mention Service in this scope.

Signal strength

Complaint signal is 10.8% across available platforms.

Praise signal is 46.7% across available platforms.

Next step

Use these topic signals to prioritize one local review point, then check fresh reviews to confirm whether the pattern changed.

Use this global view as a baseline before drilling into country, subdivision, or city-level topic patterns.

Service patterns usually point to operational choices that directly affect conversion and repeat visits for local businesses.

Evidence behind this topic

  • Service groups review language such as service, staff, assistance, support, help, and wait time, so the signal stays tied to concrete guest wording rather than a generic score.
  • New York, United States uses 74599 analyzed reviews across 2 platforms, 8 locality records, and 1053 supporting insight pages for Service.
  • Tripadvisor has the strongest complaint signal for Service at 11.9%, compared with a measured average of 10.8% across platforms.
  • Tripadvisor has the strongest praise signal for Service at 55.7%, compared with a measured average of 46.7% across platforms.

Comparison

Benchmark comparison is loading below.

Top recurring drivers

These are the strongest recurring drivers behind this topic in the current scope.

Google Maps Top complaints
A very big warning against the Da Vinci Hotel, which will be quite difficult to find as their quite dirty old front is somewhat hidden in the quite dirty street they're located in, and doesn’t reflect their prices. In general, the hotel is nothing like on the website - while looking like a fancy boutique hotel on the official pictures, the lobby is quite shabby and there’s a strong odour of the quite distinct rat- and cockroach repellent which is being used in old buildings in New York. As the hotel has a restaurant in the basement and is old and unmaintained, the pests come up to the rooms and there was a quite large cockroach in my room. My room was their most expensive category and the TV, which I had paid a lot of money to be able to relax in front of, did not work. The hotel staff and management were quite arrogant about it, just said the maintenance person was “out of town” all day and evening - and maybe the next day too. A Wednesday in Times Square? Booking.com did what they could to get my money back from the management but didn’t succeed and instead gave me a voucher. There’s in particular one receptionist who's quite nasty, will speak your first name in a condescending way etc. Both receptionists were shockingly dishonest. Also, please note that unless you buy the most expensive category, which is often more expensive than the last-minute deals at the nearby Hilton and Marriott hotels, your room will face back walls and noisy restaurant fans, not a very charming situation. This review will go back on top of Google a couple of times a month to warn other travellers as I know how much most people look forward to their sometimes once-in-a-lifetime New York trip. Furthermore, many people don’t like to leave negative feedback or forget to leave it and just stay away. Do yourself a favour and choose any other hotel in the area. Da Vinci Hotel clearly does not deserve to be in business and probably won't be for very much longer. Give yourself a better New York experience than described in the above - You deserve it.
Google Maps Top complaints
Rude staff
Google Maps Top complaints
Terrible service
Google Maps Top praises
Amazing stay! The room was clean, spacious, and the staff were incredibly welcoming. Would definitely come back!
Google Maps Top praises
Very friendly staff.
Google Maps Top praises
Absolutely loved it. The attention to detail and service were amazing
Tripadvisor Top complaints
$ 9.99 for 5 cheese sticks tasted like they were frozen. We went with a groupon and were treated second class. Was told the Groupon would only cover dinner items ( Groupon said anything on the menu ) Would not give us the salads that came with the dinner items. And the sauces were not as good a Olive Garden and I don't consider Olive Garden a good example of Italian food. The back room was much better looking than the garish front. So, I thought the value was poor, the service somewhat hostile and the food mediocre. Would never go back
Tripadvisor Top complaints
$71 for a dry meager piece of Dover sole without any side dish is over the top ridiculous even for Manhattan. This was a special so the price wasn’t noted anywhere. I might have asked the waitress for the price but we were entertaining a friend from Europe & didn’t want to appear tacky. If the fish was extraordinary I would have overlooked the expense but unfortunately this wasn’t the case. The bill for four people for 2 cocktails, 1 glass of wine,1 coke & 3 fish and 1 chicken dish with no appetizers or desert was with tip over $400- there are many, many other great restaurants in New York -skip this one
Tripadvisor Top complaints
0,5/5. We had dinner at the Il Cortile Restaurant yesterday night. Can’t believe we took a cab to get there on time, then we had to wait because we were 5min early. Bartender doesn’t know anything about wine. When we got to the table the waiter was nervous and agressive. We had to wait 1h to get our pasta while sipping this horrible French white wine that we couldn’t taste before ordering it. The food was bellow average, most of it ended up in the garbage. Last but not least we threw up in the toilet because of the bad wine. Ended up with a bill of 209$ for 3 dishes and a bottle of wine. I would never recommend this place to anyone! Careful about the doubtful reviews.
Tripadvisor Top praises
$7 burger + more for add-ons, which were not skimpy. 2 for 1 drinks. Dive bar atmosphere with friendly staff

Representative review quotes

Representative review excerpts add operational context to the topic signals.

Google Maps Complaint quote
Drinks are great. But the security guy was extremely rude and was screaming at people unnecessarily.

Review rating: 1.0

Google Maps Praise quote
Great mixology here, great cocktails. I really enjoy having great conversations here. I come here often, and service has always been great. Prices are a bit reasonable for what you get, but it's a good time every time I'm in the Chinatown area. Great place!

Review rating: 5.0

Tripadvisor Complaint quote
We thought this tour would maximize our short transfer window in BA on our way to Patagonia. Wrong! We asked for an airport pickup a month ahead…no response…asked a week ahead…no response…asked 2 days before and requested a response by noon the next day or we would cancel within 24 hours for full refund. They confirmed 20 minutes before the cancel window. As we were literally going thru customs at that time, I quickly looked and didn’t see the time, which was 3 hours after we landed. They quoted a pickup charge that was 3x the cost of an Uber so you can see how I would assume they would “follow the flight” like all other airport pickup services we have booked. Apparently they go by the fixed drop down, which doesn’t offer options from 12-2. I tried reaching them via TripAdvisor messaging, what’s app messaging (which is AI false cheerfulness who said “they can’t provide hours or number where I can talk to a live person.”) They don’t care about customer service; horrible communications; unless you can commit to a fixed location at a fixed time, don’t book.

Review rating: 1.0

Tripadvisor Praise quote
We worked with Connie at Buenos Aires Tours and she was fabulous. She helped us plan our entire trip from Buenos Aires, Iguazu Falls, Salta, Jujuy and Patagonia. She booked all our flights and hotels and excursions catering it to our needs and price points. The trip was incredible and went off without a hitch. She always checked in on us to make sure which was greatly appreciated. She also helped me out on my flight home ( which I booked) and went to great effort to ensure I was on the flight and checked in. I would highly recommend Connie and her guides were outstanding in each region. Robin Cooper

Review rating: 5.0

Evidence from source analysis

These snippets come from aggregated analysis text and highlight recurring language tied to this topic.

Google Maps Complaint signal
A very big warning against the Da Vinci Hotel, which will be quite difficult to find as their quite dirty old front is somewhat hidden in the quite dirty street they're located in, and doesn’t reflect their prices. In general, the hotel is nothing like on the website - while looking like a fancy boutique hotel on the official pictures, the lobby is quite shabby and there’s a strong odour of the quite distinct rat- and cockroach repellent which is being used in old buildings in New York. As the hotel has a restaurant in the basement and is old and unmaintained, the pests come up to the rooms and there was a quite large cockroach in my room. My room was their most expensive category and the TV, which I had paid a lot of money to be able to relax in front of, did not work. The hotel staff and management were quite arrogant about it, just said the maintenance person was “out of town” all day and evening - and maybe the next day too. A Wednesday in Times Square? Booking.com did what they could to get my money back from the management but didn’t succeed and instead gave me a voucher. There’s in particular one receptionist who's quite nasty, will speak your first name in a condescending way etc. Both receptionists were shockingly dishonest. Also, please note that unless you buy the most expensive category, which is often more expensive than the last-minute deals at the nearby Hilton and Marriott hotels, your room will face back walls and noisy restaurant fans, not a very charming situation. This review will go back on top of Google a couple of times a month to warn other travellers as I know how much most people look forward to their sometimes once-in-a-lifetime New York trip. Furthermore, many people don’t like to leave negative feedback or forget to leave it and just stay away. Do yourself a favour and choose any other hotel in the area. Da Vinci Hotel clearly does not deserve to be in business and probably won't be for very much longer. Give yourself a better New York experience than described in the above - You deserve it.

Signal: 0.0%

Google Maps Complaint signal
Rude staff

Signal: 0.0%

Google Maps Complaint signal
Terrible service

Signal: 0.0%

Google Maps Praise signal
Amazing stay! The room was clean, spacious, and the staff were incredibly welcoming. Would definitely come back!

Signal: 0.0%

Google Maps Praise signal
Very friendly staff.

Signal: 0.0%

Google Maps Praise signal
Absolutely loved it. The attention to detail and service were amazing

Signal: 0.0%

Quality and confidence

Check coverage and freshness before treating differences as operational priorities.

Reviews analyzed

74,599

Platforms covered

2

Last update

June 27, 2026

Guided journey

Move through these pages in order to validate findings and choose the next local review point.

FAQ

Related insights

Review source articles behind this topic before choosing the next local review point.

Google Maps

Restaurants

Buffalo restaurants on Google Maps

The Google Maps snapshot of Buffalo, NY restaurants shows a strong market signal with 70 restaurants and 46,618 published reviews, achieving a 4.45 average...

Buffalo · June 24, 2026 Read Full Insight

TripAdvisor

Restaurants

Buffalo restaurants on TripAdvisor

TripAdvisor’s Buffalo restaurant snapshot shows a solid 4.18 average rating across 97 venues with 29,315 published reviews, but operator focus should be on...

Buffalo · June 24, 2026 Read Full Insight

Google Maps

Bars

New York bars on Google Maps

Google Maps data shows New York bars enjoy a high average rating but reveal distinct strengths in food and service alongside price and cleanliness...

New York · June 24, 2026 Read Full Insight

TripAdvisor

Bars

New York bars on TripAdvisor

TripAdvisor data for bars in New York, NY shows a modest average rating of 4.09 across 71 venues with 15,878 published reviews, highlighting key strengths...

New York · June 24, 2026 Read Full Insight

Google Maps

Cafes

New York cafes on Google Maps

Google Maps provides a snapshot of New York cafes with a strong overall rating, highlighting service strength, price sensitivity, and mixed atmosphere...

New York · June 24, 2026 Read Full Insight

TripAdvisor

Cafes

New York cafes on TripAdvisor

TripAdvisor data for New York cafés shows a strong overall rating of 4.29 with a high share of positive sentiment, but operators must focus on service...

New York · June 24, 2026 Read Full Insight

Google Maps

Hotels

New York hotels on Google Maps

Google Maps data shows New York hotels hold a 4.09 average rating across 102 analyzed locations and 131280 published reviews, with guests consistently...

New York · June 24, 2026 Read Full Insight

TripAdvisor

Hotels

New York hotels on TripAdvisor

TripAdvisor analysis of New York hotels shows an average rating of 3.97 across 134 hotels, with 335631 published reviews revealing strong location appeal...

New York · June 24, 2026 Read Full Insight

Google Maps

Restaurants

New York restaurants on Google Maps

Google Maps data for New York restaurants shows a strong overall impression with an average rating of 4.36 across 86 venues and nearly 100 k published...

New York · June 24, 2026 Read Full Insight

TripAdvisor

Restaurants

New York restaurants on TripAdvisor

TripAdvisor data for New York restaurants shows a strong overall rating of 4.28 while highlighting service as a key strength, mixed value perception, and...

New York · June 24, 2026 Read Full Insight